Kitchen Sink Soup
Soups and Stews - That One's a Keeper!

Chicken Casserole
Main Dishes - That One's a Keeper!

Hodgepodge soup  
Soups and Stews - That One's a Keeper!

Baklava
Cookies and Candies - That One's a Keeper!

Deb's chicken soup
Soups and Stews - That One's a Keeper!

Janet's Baked Beans
Main Dishes - That One's a Keeper!

Cole Slaw or Cucumber Salad
Soups and Stews - That One's a Keeper!

Granny's Scalloped potatoes
Main Dishes - That One's a Keeper!

Stuffed Peppers
Main Dishes - That One's a Keeper!

Mom's Meat Loaf
Main Dishes - That One's a Keeper!

Peach Pie
Cakes, Puddings, and Pies - That One's a Keeper!

THE Pie Crust Recipe (Perfect Pie Dough (by Cook's Illustrated)
Cakes, Puddings, and Pies - That One's a Keeper!

Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge
Cookies and Candies - That One's a Keeper!

Oatmeal Cookies
Cookies and Candies - That One's a Keeper!

Weight Watchers Veggie Soup (the good one)
Soups and Stews - That One's a Keeper!

Galactoboureko (Greek semolina pie)
Cakes, Puddings, and Pies - That One's a Keeper!

Creamy Rice Pudding
Cakes, Puddings, and Pies - That One's a Keeper!

Gingersnaps
Cookies and Candies - That One's a Keeper!

Chewy caramel bars
Cookies and Candies - That One's a Keeper!

U.C.C. Bread
Breads and muffins - That One's a Keeper!